Published: April 2026
At some point, every growing Australian business faces the same question: who should be running the numbers? The bookkeeper who has been handling things since day one is stretched. The owner is spending Sunday nights trying to make sense of the P&L. BAS keeps creeping up on the deadline. And nobody is doing the strategic work: cashflow forecasting, scenario planning, pricing analysis, or preparing the business for what comes next.
The three most common options are hiring a bookkeeper, hiring a full-time finance manager or financial controller, or engaging a fractional CFO. Each costs a different amount, delivers a different level of capability, and suits a different stage of business. This guide compares all three with specific dollar figures so you can make the right call for where your business is today. If you want a personalised recommendation, our hire vs outsource decision wizard walks you through the key factors and suggests the right model for your situation.
A bookkeeper handles the operational layer of your finance function. They reconcile your bank accounts, code transactions, process payroll, prepare BAS for lodgement, and manage basic accounts payable and receivable. A good bookkeeper keeps the machine running. What they do not do is tell you what the machine is producing, whether it is efficient, or where it is heading.
Cost as an employee: $55,000 to $80,000 base salary. After super at 12%, annual leave, sick leave, payroll tax (if you are above your state threshold), and workers compensation, the loaded cost is $72,000 to $105,000 per year. Add recruitment costs of $8,000 to $20,000 in year one.
Cost as an outsourced service: $300 to $2,500 per month, depending on transaction volume and scope. See our cost of bookkeeping guide for a detailed breakdown by business size.
Where bookkeepers max out: typically around $2 million to $3 million in revenue. At that point, the business needs more than accurate records. It needs analysis, forecasting, and strategic input. The bookkeeper is still essential, but they cannot fill the gap alone.
Common failure mode: the owner is still making every financial decision without data-driven input. The bookkeeper provides the raw numbers but nobody is interpreting them, challenging them, or using them to plan ahead.
Not sure if you still only need a bookkeeper? Our free assessment tool can help you figure that out.
A finance manager or controller sits between the bookkeeper and the CFO. They own the month-end close process, produce management reports (P&L, balance sheet, cashflow statement), oversee budgeting and variance analysis, manage cashflow, and supervise the bookkeeping function. In larger businesses, they also handle audit preparation and finance team management.
Cost as an employee: $120,000 to $170,000 base salary depending on experience and location. Sydney commands the highest rates, with the median sitting around $155,000 according to 2026 salary guide data. After super ($14,400 to $20,400), payroll tax, leave entitlements, workers compensation, equipment, and professional development, the loaded cost is $155,000 to $220,000 per year. First-year cost including recruitment agency fees (typically 15 to 25 per cent of base salary): $175,000 to $260,000. For the full calculation, see our finance team salary costs breakdown, or model it with our employee cost calculator.
The single biggest issue with hiring a full-time finance manager in an SME: the bookkeeping trap. In businesses without a separate bookkeeper, the finance manager inevitably spends 50 to 60 per cent of their time on bookkeeping tasks. Reconciliation, invoice processing, chasing debtors, running payroll. That is $170,000 for someone doing $60,000 work half the time. It happens because there is nobody else to do the operational work, no budget for a separate bookkeeper, and the finance manager defaults to the urgent tasks rather than the important ones.
Other risks: single point of failure (what happens when they go on leave or resign?), recruitment timeline of 2 to 3 months, onboarding and ramp-up of another 3 months, and average tenure of 3 to 4 years before you repeat the cycle. Our cost of a bad hire analysis shows what happens when the wrong person is in the seat.
A fractional CFO provides strategic financial leadership on a part-time basis. They work with your business 5 to 15 hours per week, focusing on the things that move the needle: cashflow strategy, pricing analysis, capital allocation, board and investor reporting, exit planning, and financial decision support. They do not do the bookkeeping. They work with your existing bookkeeper (or outsourced team) and add the strategic layer on top.
Cost: $3,000 to $8,000 per month, or $36,000 to $96,000 per year. See our fractional CFO costs guide for a full breakdown.
The fractional CFO model works well when you already have a competent bookkeeper handling operations and you need strategic oversight. The limitation is that if your bookkeeping is not solid, the CFO is building on shaky foundations. They will spend time identifying problems in the operational data rather than doing the strategic work you are paying them for.
Between $2 million and $15 million in revenue, most Australian SMEs fall into a gap. The bookkeeper is not enough, but the full-time finance manager is too expensive or too risky as a single hire. The business needs both operational finance (bookkeeping, payroll, BAS) and strategic finance (reporting, forecasting, advisory). But those are two different skill sets at two different price points.
The symptoms are consistent: the bookkeeper is overwhelmed and behind on reconciliation, monthly reporting is late or non-existent, cashflow surprises keep happening (especially at BAS time), the owner is spending 5 to 10 hours per week on finance instead of running the business, and important decisions about pricing, hiring, or investment are being made on gut feel rather than data.
Hiring a finance manager solves the capability problem but creates a cost problem ($155,000 to $220,000 loaded) and a risk problem (single point of failure, recruitment cycle every 3 to 4 years). And half of that expensive hire's time gets consumed by the operational work anyway.
This is why the blended team model has gained traction in Australia. An outsourced team combines operational finance support at the appropriate cost level with senior CA oversight for the strategic layer. You get the bookkeeping done by people who specialise in it, reporting and analysis done by mid-level CPAs, and strategic oversight from a senior Chartered Accountant. All for a fraction of the cost of a single full-time hire.
A Melbourne-based consultancy at $3.2 million revenue with 10 employees. The owner currently uses a part-time bookkeeper ($1,200 per month) and does everything else themselves, including payroll, cashflow tracking, and financial decision-making.
Option A: Bookkeeper only (current state). Cost: $14,400 per year plus approximately $15,000 per year in owner time. Total: $29,400. Result: books are reconciled monthly, BAS gets lodged, but the owner has no management reporting, no cashflow forecast, and makes financial decisions based on the bank balance.
Option B: Hire a finance manager. Year 1 cost: approximately $195,000 (salary of $130,000 plus on-costs of $35,000 plus recruitment of $30,000). Ongoing: $165,000 per year. Result: proper reporting and oversight, but 50 per cent of the finance manager's time is spent on bookkeeping. Expensive, and a single point of failure.
Option C: Outsourced blended team. Cost: $2,200 per month, or $26,400 per year. Includes weekly bookkeeping, fortnightly payroll, BAS lodgement, monthly management accounts, and quarterly strategy call with a senior CA. Result: more capability than Option A, lower cost than Option B, no recruitment risk, no leave liability.
A Sydney-based IT services company at $7.4 million revenue with 22 employees across NSW and Queensland. Currently has an in-house bookkeeper ($75,000 base, $98,000 loaded) and uses an external accountant for quarterly reporting ($6,000 per year).
Option A: Add a fractional CFO on top of existing bookkeeper. Bookkeeper: $98,000. Fractional CFO at $5,000 per month: $60,000. Total: $158,000 per year. Works well but creates two provider relationships and coordination overhead.
Option B: Replace bookkeeper with outsourced team at $4,200 per month ($50,400 per year). Team includes operational bookkeeping, payroll with multi-state payroll tax, management reporting, cashflow forecasting, and senior CA oversight. Total: $50,400. Saving versus Option A: $107,600 per year. Plus eliminates the risk of the bookkeeper resigning (which would cost $15,000 to $25,000 in recruitment and productivity loss per our turnover data).
A Perth-based construction company at $12 million revenue with 45 employees across multiple awards, operating in WA and SA. Currently has a bookkeeper ($70,000 base) and a financial controller ($155,000 base). Total loaded cost: approximately $300,000 per year.
Outsourced team at $5,800 per month: $69,600 per year. This is a significant cost reduction, but the real question at this size is whether the outsourced model can handle the complexity. Multi-entity, multi-state, enterprise agreements, complex award interpretation, job costing. At $12 million with 45 employees, this is approaching the point where a full-time controller starts to make sense. The outsourced team may be the right answer for another 12 to 18 months while the business determines whether it is heading to $20 million (justify the hire) or plateauing (keep the outsourced model).
For a $5 million revenue business, here is what each option costs over five years, assuming one turnover event for internal hires at year three.
Option A: Bookkeeper only. $72,000 to $105,000 per year, plus one recruitment cycle ($15,000). Five-year total: $375,000 to $540,000. But there is a strategic gap the entire time. No forecasting, no management reporting, no advisory.
Option B: Full-time finance manager. Year 1: $195,000 to $260,000 (including recruitment). Years 2 and 3: $155,000 to $220,000 per year. Year 3 turnover event: $25,000 recruitment plus 3 months reduced productivity ($40,000). Years 4 and 5: $155,000 to $220,000 per year. Five-year total: $880,000 to $1,180,000.
Option C: Outsourced blended team at $3,500 per month. $42,000 per year. Five-year total: $210,000. No recruitment costs, no turnover events, no leave liability, no ramp-up periods.
Option D: Bookkeeper plus separate fractional CFO. Bookkeeper at $85,000 loaded plus CFO at $60,000 per year plus one bookkeeper turnover ($15,000). Five-year total: $740,000. Works, but more expensive than the blended team and requires managing two relationships.
Use our hire vs outsource calculator to model this for your specific numbers.
Below $1 million: a bookkeeper is sufficient. Keep it simple, keep it cheap, focus on building the business.
$1 million to $3 million: bookkeeper plus periodic accountant engagement. Start thinking about monthly reporting but the volume does not yet justify a full team.
$3 million to $15 million: this is the sweet spot for a blended outsourced team. The business needs operational finance, reporting, and strategic oversight, but cannot justify the loaded cost of building that capability internally. An outsourced team with CA oversight delivers more capability at a fraction of the cost. This is the range where the complexity of the finance function increases significantly.
Above $15 million with high complexity: a full-time financial controller or finance manager starts to make sense, potentially supplemented by a fractional CFO for strategic input. The volume and complexity justify a dedicated in-house resource, and the business can afford the loaded cost.
Week 1: Junior analyst reconciles bank accounts, processes accounts payable and receivable, runs the fortnightly payroll cycle, and codes new transactions in Xero.
Week 2: Mid-level CPA reviews the month-end close, prepares the management reporting pack (P&L with variance commentary, balance sheet review, cashflow statement), and flags any anomalies.
Week 3: Senior CA reviews the reports, prepares or updates the cashflow forecast, reviews any compliance matters (BAS preparation, payroll tax, super), and flags strategic items for discussion.
Week 4: Strategy call with the business owner to discuss the numbers, upcoming decisions (hiring, investment, pricing changes), and forward planning.
Compare this with the typical in-house finance manager: Monday to Wednesday spent on bookkeeping tasks (because nobody else is doing them), Thursday on reporting, and Friday trying to squeeze in the strategic thinking they never quite have time for. By the time they get to the important work, the week is over.
Our hiring a finance manager vs outsourcing guide provides a more detailed comparison of both models in practice.
Not directly. A fractional CFO provides strategic oversight, not operational execution. They can replace the strategic component of a finance manager's role, but someone still needs to handle the day-to-day bookkeeping, payroll, and reconciliation. The blended team model solves this by combining both layers: operational support from junior and mid-level staff, and strategic oversight from a senior CA. That way you get the full finance function without the full-time salary.
Typically 5 to 15 hours per week, depending on the engagement scope and your business complexity. At $3,000 per month, expect around 5 to 8 hours per week. At $8,000 per month, expect 12 to 15 hours. The hours are focused entirely on strategic work: reporting review, cashflow management, decision support, and board preparation. No time is spent on bookkeeping or data entry.
Yes, and this is a common arrangement. The fractional CFO works with the output your bookkeeper produces and adds the strategic layer. The risk is that if your bookkeeper's work is not reliable, the CFO spends time identifying and correcting errors rather than doing strategic work. If you are considering this approach, make sure your bookkeeper is producing clean, timely data first. Our P&L health score can help you assess whether your current reporting is solid enough to support strategic decision-making.
As a general guide, when your business consistently exceeds $15 million in revenue and has the complexity (multiple entities, multiple states, enterprise agreements, or international operations) to justify a dedicated senior finance resource at $155,000 to $220,000 loaded cost per year. Below that threshold, the outsourced team model typically delivers equal or better capability at significantly lower cost. Use our revenue per employee benchmark to see whether your business has the revenue base to support additional headcount.
Significantly less expensive. An outsourced blended team at $3,000 to $6,000 per month costs $36,000 to $72,000 per year. The equivalent internal capability (bookkeeper plus finance manager) costs $243,000 to $318,000 loaded per year. That is a saving of $171,000 to $282,000 annually. Over five years, the cumulative saving can exceed $1 million when you include recruitment, turnover, and ramp-up costs that internal hires incur.
The transition typically happens in stages. Month 1: the outsourced team takes over bookkeeping and reconciliation, mirroring what your current bookkeeper does but at a higher frequency (weekly instead of monthly). Month 2: management reporting begins, giving you a monthly P&L with variance commentary and a balance sheet review. Month 3: cashflow forecasting and strategic review start. By month 3, you have a fully functioning finance team. Your existing bookkeeper can either transition to a different role in the business or their engagement can wind down naturally. Most providers handle this transition within 4 to 6 weeks.
Scale Suite is a Sydney-based provider of outsourced finance and HR services for Australian SMEs. We deliver weekly bookkeeping, payroll, BAS/IAS lodgement, cashflow reporting, management accounts, and strategic fractional CFO oversight as a fully embedded team that works inside your business. Employment Hero Gold Partner, CA-qualified, Xero Certified, and registered BAS Agents. No lock-in contracts and a 30-day money-back guarantee.
Learn more at scalesuite.com.au/services/finance
We review and check this guide periodically. At the time of writing (April 2026), all pricing and regulatory information was current. Some details may change over time as ATO requirements and market rates evolve.
Scale Suite is a Sydney-based provider of outsourced finance and HR services for Australian SMEs. We deliver bookkeeping, financial reporting, payroll processing, fractional CFO support, recruitment, employee onboarding, people and culture support, and fractional HR oversight, all as a fully embedded team that works inside your business.
Employment Hero Gold Partner, CA-qualified, and Xero Certified, we replace fragmented finance and HR processes with one responsive, senior-level function at a fraction of the cost of full-time hires. We serve growing businesses across Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane, and Perth, with packages starting from $1,500 per month and no lock-in contracts.
Considering hiring finance staff?
We'll show you the full cost of an internal hire vs our embedded team, and exactly how much you'd save.
We'll reply within 24 hours to book your free 30-minute call.
No lock-in contracts and 30-day money-back guarantee.
Prefer to book directly? Schedule your free 30-minute call here
